- How does a community determine who belongs and who does not? How does a society determine its “universe of obligation?”
As a group we believed that their is not a particular way that a community determines who belongs and who does not. However, we believed that the most common way to determine which is which is mostly by profiling. It can be any type of profiling, but we think that racial profiling plays the biggest part. We remember in a video that a black man had said that he was walking down the street, going home, after church. A police officer thought he did not belong in the place he was in and thought he was up to no good. He arrested the black man because of racial profiling. A lot of times, for example, if someone new moves into to your neighborhood and you see them, you judge them by their first impression. You see some of things they own and you get this picture of who they are and what they are made of. But the first time you meet them they are a completely different person then you thought. We believe that this is almost all communities “universe of obligation”. We determine who does and doesn’t belong based on what they look like to us, not what they really are. And this can lead to dramatic changes in ones personality and public appearance.
2. What are the consequences for those who choose to challenge a community’s rules—written and unwritten—about who belongs?
- Atticus
- Miss Maudie Atkinson
- Boo Radley
- Tom Robinson
There can be many different consequences, not all linked with the law. Atticus is put on a case with a man named Tom Robinson. Tom was accused of raping a white woman and was arrested. Originally, Atticus said that he wasn’t really going to put much effort into the trial. But after a day into the trial, Atticus realized that Tom was falsely accused. He vowed that he would try his hardest to get Tom free of this accusation. This lead to many consequences, and not just for him. His whole family was being slammed in the face with a lot of hate. Everyone else believed that Tom really did rape the woman and began thinking that Atticus was wrong in the head. Even some of their family turned on them. On page 86, Scout says, “…why did Cecil say you defended …,” People begin to judge the Finch family and people, for example Cecil, is beginning to be rude to Atticus and his children. Scout actually gets into a fight over her father’s actions, trying to protect her dads title. In conclusion, Atticus chooses to challenge the community’s unwritten rules, and him and his family are paying the price.
3. What dilemmas do individuals confront when their consciences conflict with the rules and expectations of their communities? What conflicts arise in literature out of the tension between characters and their settings?
One of the dilemmas that is confronted upon one of the main characters is Atticus’ choice on the trial of Tom Robinson. Atticus has to choose between two options, each leading a different direction. He can let an innocent Tom Robinson get sent to prison, or even possibly executed, or he could serve justice and do his best to let the innocent man go. Atticus, being the kind hearted and equally minded person he is, chooses to help Tom stay a free man. Even though he believes this is right, everyone around thinks and tells him that he is wrong. He continues to fight for Tom however, not caring entirely of the consequences. Many different conflicts begin to rise up because of Atticus’ choices. His daughter Scout begin to learn about all of these things she had never seen before. She begins to learn about racism, and begins being bullied about her dad being a … defender. She starts getting into fights at school about the whole trial. All of these are conflicts that are raising because of Atticus’ choices and the tension between characters and their settings.